Ample Hills Creamery logo
Ample Hills Creamery

Dining · 4+ locations · Brooklyn: Prospect Heights, Washington Ave; Manhattan: Upper West Side; Queens: Astoria

Ample Hills looks like classic indie Brooklyn ice cream, but its founders don't run it anymore. After a 2020 bankruptcy and a brief 2023 comeback, Brian Smith and Jackie Cuscuna were fired by their own investors — the shops now answer to that group instead.

Investor-backed

The Big Picture

Mixed Picture

Ample Hills survived one bankruptcy only to end up controlled by the investors who backed its second act — its own founders were forced out seven months after buying the brand back. Brian Smith and Jackie Cuscuna built the company, lost it in a 2020 bankruptcy sale, briefly reclaimed it in 2023, then were fired by their own lead investor within the year. Its day-to-day conduct record is clean, but it now answers to that investor group and the CEO they installed, not to the people who started it.

Let's Get Critical

Local ownership
3/10
Founder involvement
3/10
Worker pay & benefits
6/10
Environmental impact
6/10
Sourcing & labor
5/10

Tap to see why these scores

What do these scores mean? Learn more.

Make a New Choice

Caffè Pannaview
Malaiview
Davey's Ice Creamview
Explore all dining

Company data last updated July 2026

How does one person build and research all this? They don't: here's how it actually works. Verdicts are our opinions, based on the public sources cited above as of July 2026. Spotted something off? or learn more.