Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie
Dining · 1 location · Brooklyn: Red Hook
The walk-up window at the end of Van Dyke Street looks like a one-man pie stand. Behind it is a 6,000-square-foot bakery that has sold one dessert wholesale across the city for decades, still owned by the husband and wife who started it.
The Big Picture
Steve Tarpin and his wife Victoria run Steve's Authentic themselves, and no investor, parent company, or franchise system appears anywhere in its structure. As a single-location family business it has generated little public labor or environmental record to weigh, and it publishes no supplier list for the key limes at the center of its one product. The people answerable for it are the couple who own it.
Let's Get Critical
See why these scores
What do these scores mean? Learn more.
See for Yourself
Find Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie near you
Enter your neighborhood or address
Keep Discovering
Explore all diningCompany data last updated August 2026
How does one person build and research all this? They don't: here's how it actually works. Verdicts are our opinions, based on the public sources cited above as of August 2026. Spotted something off? or learn more.